UTRGV Course Material Evaluation Rubric

This rubric serves as a tool for evaluating assigned course materials, ensuring they align with institutional priorities and student needs. It provides scoring criteria across critical areas so reviewers can objectively assess the resource’s strengths and areas for improvement. The total score interpretation helps categorize the resource’s overall suitability, guiding decisions for adoption, modification, or replacement to meet educational and institutional goals effectively.

Scoring Guide:

● 3 Points: Exemplary (Meets or Exceeds Expectations)

● 2 Points: Adequate (Partial Fulfillment)

● 1 Point: Needs Improvement (Significant Gaps)

The rubric is accessible in multiple formats:

• PDF – UTRGV Course Material Evaluation Rubric
• Excel – UTRGV Course Material Evaluation Rubric

Scoring Interpretation:

● Total Score 30-36: Exceptional Resource (Highly Recommended)

● Total Score 22-29: Adequate Resource (Consider with Modifications)

● Total Score 12-21: Resource Needs Significant Improvement

● Total Score 11 or Below: Reconsider Adoption

Attributions:

^{This work was created by guiding AI with existing Openly Licensed OER evaluation rubrics to prompt and create this work: Openly Licensed OER Evaluation Rubrics. UTRGV Course Material Evaluation Rubric by Gabby Hernandez and Xandra Okori with assistance from AI is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0}